It’s a hard choice to recommend for because it is based on a companion you’ve spent the most time with. So depending on how you have been playing and feel about that companion will really drive the choice. In my first play through it was between Sarah and Andreja. Sarah had been my companion for the first 20ish hours and then I switched to Andreja to do her questline and ended up liking her around more (versus Sarah constantly making remarks about disagreeing with me). So it was easy to let Sarah die. Hope that makes sense.

@Thundergorge it does but with her also being the chair of constellation to me it would make sense to keep her alive but on the other hand you are right haha she does complain a lot. So far I do like Barrett and Sam Coe, and the other person you mentioned. If I use all three and barely use Sarah she will die right? So I know you can either go to the Eye or stay at the lodge. What is the “easiest” way to do this quest? Thanks for the help!!!

Not necessarily, it still comes down to a choice between two and it’s really just whoever you “abandon”. But that’s not even really it as again depending on how you play or roleplay experience I’d say in story, Sarah should be the most capable to go “solo” as the leader of constellation and her background. Though that has no actual bearing on it as whoever you leave will die regardless.

For what it’s worth too without going into spoilers about NG+ you can also make your choice differently each time and have different companions too. I had one instance where Andreja didn’t exist, another where everyone in constellation was already dead too.

So then in my first play through and I know everyone is different but who you think is best to let go and where should I go? Lodge or Eye? Cause either way from what I’ve seen or read it all plays out same way for the most part.

Well wherev you go you will fight starborn so think of it as do you want to fight in a more open (lodge) or confined (eye) location. There’s also another set of choices near the end of a playthrough that takes some consideration in what loot you can get and how long you can use it. That one is really just how hard you want the last fight to be/your principles. Here you could conceivably “avenge” your comrade and make the final choice based on what best honors their memory.

The last choice is essentially whether you want to go into ng+, just be aware that if you opt for the ng+ you keep your skills but lose all gear so that shiny weapon(s) you get in the final fight don’t carry over if you actually want to use them.

I just let Sam die because his duaghter has the most emotional and powerful reaction. Plus it just makes sense.

Yeah the encounter I had in NG+ was her all alone and everyone else dead and it was pretty brutal

I’m thinking ahead and I just can’t decide because I like them all minus Sarah grumbling all the time…..guess what I will have to do is look at their skills and which one doesn’t work with my character runs I will just try it that way. I’m currently going on a Cyberneticist and Space Scoundrel run. Haha I’ve named my characters from movies. The cyberneticist is Wolverine, and yes I tried my best to make it look like him and then my space scoundrel is Han Solo……with Han Solo I did a very old look with a full blown beard…..yeah I know he didn’t have one in the movies but I put my own twist on it haha. Gotta have fun right?